We would like to thank the Minister Esther McVey for responding to our letter dated
11th April via one of our founders Anna Kennedy. We are pleased to hear that she "greatly admires and
appreciates the valuable work" that we do,
however we are very disappointed that she is unable to meet with us to discuss
the concerns we raised again with her about the PIP assessment process
(and the WCA) for adults with autism.
We
feel the response from the Minister has somewhat missed the point(s) we raised. While we are fully aware that adults with
autism are allowed an appointee and encouraged to take a companion with
them, during face to face assessments, this does not always happen. Also the very nature of the condition means that some adults
with autism will simply not have anyone whom they can ask to accompany
them to an assessment.
Here is her reply, apologies for the poor (and squint) quality!
The
point that we were hoping to convey is autism impacts
on all forms of communication, including written communication. That
is why it is essential that an autism specific advocate is offered at the first point of contact by the DWP, ATOS or JobcentrePlus.
We know it is the adults who have not had the
support of an advocate, while they are completing their
ESA 50 questionnaire, who are most likely to find themselves having a face to
face assessment and then being placed wrongly in a Work Related Activity Group whilst facing the trauma of having to launch an appeal.
The
point we were hoping to make to the Minister is that the whole assessment
process discriminates against autistic adults because they have a communication and socialisation
impairment.
Once again we reiterated there are a significant number of autistic adults who do not have the historical or medical data they require for decision makers to make a decision as to
whether or not they might have to have a face to face assessment. There
are many adults who have been without services and provision after
being signed off by Children’s Services.
No services and no provision does not equal someone who is not in need support!
We know that autistic adults are at a distinct disadvantage to other
people with disabilities in the current system simply because they have either been unable to
access services and provision, or the services and provision did not
exist for them to access in the first place.
We
are extremely frustrated that no one within the Coalition Government
and DWP appears to be able to understand that adults with autism are going to
find themselves discriminated against and disadvantaged throughout the
whole PIP process, as they are throughout the whole WCA process.
We will write again to the Minister and continue to reiterate these points!

Is this really what our adults with autism have got to look forward to for the rest of their lives?
Have you ever read the book or watched the film The NeverEnding Story?
Bastian Bux a quiet boy who loves to read is accosted by bullies on
his way to school. He hides in a bookstore, interrupting the grumpy
bookseller. Bastian "borrows" a book, leaving a note promising to return
it, and races towards school. He then hides in the school's attic to
begin reading The Neverending Story.
The
book describes the fantasy world of Fantasia which is being threatened
by a force called "The Nothing," a void of darkness that consumes
everything.
April 30th marks the end of Autism Awareness Month. A month that has
seen some amazing autism awareness and acceptance blogs and events held
all over the world.
Adults with autism and parents and cares have worked hard to improve
the level of awareness, understanding and perception, that those who are
not living with autism have about the multi faceted and multi coloured
condition that we call autism.
So as we leave Autism Awareness Month behind us for another year, I
decided to write a blog that I am afraid will paint a pretty grim
picture of what living with autism, after the age of 16, can be like for
young people and adults with the condition here in the UK.
I
make no apologies for the title of my blog ‘The Nothing’ because for
many post 16 children and adults with autism that is exactly what they
have to look forward to. NOTHING!
In fact despite all of the fighting that parents do on behalf of their
children, to ensure that they get a half decent education and that at
least some of their complex needs are met, the sad truth is that with
every year that passes far too many children are marching on towards ‘The Nothing’
Our Lives in your hands Ambitious About Autism. March 2013
“Less than 1 in 4 young people with autism continue their education beyond school.”
Transition Report APPGA - Effective and timely planning – 2009
“Many
young people with autism often find that planning for their futures
does not happen. Frequently, decisions about a young person’s next
placement are made only when they are approaching the end of their
schooling or, worse still, after they have left school. In the vast
majority of cases where transition planning is taking place, it is
happening without the involvement of adult social services. Contributors
stressed how vital it is to address this. A recurrent theme was the
mental health problems which developed, in part, as a result of these
failures.”
Realistic yet stretching expectations – APPGA Transition Report 2009
For
more able young people with autism, there is often insufficient
understanding about the level of support they will require in adult
life. Yet, for others, expectations may be too low meaning poor outcomes
become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Transition planning must explore all
areas where support may be needed to ensure young people with autism
can reach their full potential in adulthood, including employment,
independent living skills, relationship counselling, and leisure
activities.
I Exist - National Autistic Society 2008
Our research found that:
63% of adults with autism do not have the support to meet their needs
60% of parents say that a lack of support has led to higher support needs in the long run
33% of adults with autism have experienced severe mental health problems because of a lack of support
15% of adults with autism have a full-time, paid job.
Don’t Write me off – The National Autistic Society
A
third of adults with autism are currently without a job or benefits,
and many more struggle to access the right support to find a job or get
the benefits they're entitled to.
National Audit Office Report 2009
There
are few specialised employment support services for people with autism.
A lack of understanding of autism is a significant barrier to gaining
employment and more training is needed for those delivering employment
support and those administering benefits.
National Audit Office Report 2009
Around
200,000 adults with autism do not have a learning disability. This
group often fails to secure appropriate support, as health and social
care services are traditionally configured for people with a learning
disability, a physical illness or disability, or a mental health problem
(which autism is not). Three quarters of local authorities said adults
with autism who do not meet eligibility criteria experience or report
difficulties accessing the services they require. Almost two thirds felt
that current services for adults with autism are limited. Providing
specialised support could improve outcomes for this group of people and
their carers, and potentially enhance value for money, as the costs of
establishing such support could be outweighed over time by overall
savings.
Very little has changed since these reports were written, this is
despite the fact that in England we have an Autism Act and a National
Adults Autism Strategy "Fulfilling and Rewarding lives" There is nothing
very rewarding about doing NOTHING.
Twelve years ago there was no transition planning for my eldest son
and no support to ensure that he was both ready and able to seek and
maintain employment. Twelve years down the road and there is no
transition planning and no support to ensure that my youngest son is
both ready and able to seek employment.
My eldest son has seen NO ONE related to his autism since leaving Children’s Services. He is 26 years old in July.
I spoke at an All Party Parliamentary Group (APPGA) meeting in March,
where a room full of desperate parents of adults with autism ALL had the
same story to tell. Our adult children have already been consumed by
‘The Nothing’ and we are all looking for a way out of ‘The Nothing’ into
a much brighter place for them to live.
Norman Lamb, Care Minister was at the APPGA meeting where he said
“we
would never tolerate someone with cancer getting the wrong care or
treatment…and we should not tolerate someone with autism or Asperger
syndrome getting the wrong care or treatment or not getting any care at
all”.
He
added that great progress had been made in getting the legal framework
in place with the adult autism strategy and statutory guidelines but
recognised that in many places on the ground, nothing really has
changed.
The
Minister added that the upcoming review of the strategy in April is a
critical period for the Government to engage with parents and carers to
provide a thorough analysis of where we are and what needs to change.
Speaking
more generally about mental health, the Minister stated his own record
in making mental health a top priority for the government’s mandate to
the NHS commissioning board seeking parity with physical health by 2015.
Mr Lamb stressed that he was determined to make a difference in this area while he was Minister.
I, along with thousands of parents of adult children with autism, and
adults themselves, really do hope that someone, sometime soon, will make
a different, to end ‘The Nothing’ that is all that our adults have to
look forward to.
I
know how hard fighting our day to day battle for our children can be. I
know what it feels like to run on empty. I know how frightening it can
be when you have a child with autism, to look further down the road than
next week or next month. But NEVER did I know how truly desolate and
desperate I was going to feel living with one adult child with autism,
and one adolescent where the only thing that I could be sure of for
either of them was NOTHING
So PLEASE if you see anything posted about making life better for
adults with autism, if you see anything posted about the autism strategy
review where we are asking for comments or support, please support us.
Even if you just add your name to whatever it is we are fighting or
campaigning for then please do it. Your child with autism will be an
adults with autism before you can blink.
Do not sit back and do nothing. Do not let 'The Nothing' be your child's NeverEnding Story!
Carole Rutherford
Co-Founder Act Now For Autism
On
this World Autism Awareness Day, Act Now for Autism would like to focus on the need to raise awareness of autism and the need for
lifelong services, support, therapies and interventions for children and
adults with autism.
Autism is not something that can be cured
with a block of therapy or by accessing an intervention for a short
period of time. Children and adults with autism require ongoing access
to the therapies and interventions that can make a huge difference to
their lives.
If every child
with autism were able to access the speech and language therapy,
occupational therapy and sensory integration therapy (to name but a few)
that could make a difference to their lives, we would at least be giving
them the best possible chance to reach their full potential as adults.
If every adult with autism were able to access low level preventative
services as and when they needed to and advocates to enable them to
communicate effectively (especially when having their benefits assessed
or reassessed) we would be giving them the best possible chance to live
fulfilling, rewarding and independent lives.
Services and support have been removed from
our children and adults already and there are more cuts to come. We are extremely concerned that things for the autism community will become much harder. Parents, carers and adults
with autism are telling us they are very anxious, autism can often autism be a hidden disability so some children and
adults with autism will not be deemed to be severely disabled enough to
warrant support, services and provision.
Act Now for Autism is
in the process of updating the Impact Assessment Report first published in 2010. We need to
raise as much awareness about the impact that the cuts to services and
benefits are having on our lives as possible. To enable us to do this we
need our supporters to tell us how these cuts are impacting on their
lives.
Sitting back and doing nothing is not an option for us, we need your support. Together we can make our voice heard.
Please share your stories with us, about the impact of cuts upon you and your friends/family. You can comment here, on our Facebook page or via your regional Facebook group or by email mail@actnowforautism.co.uk
Act Now For Autism supports the call for a
Cumulative Impact Assessment of the Welfare Reform Act. The changes to
benefits are falling disproportionately upon disabled communities across
the UK and our particular concern is for those with hidden
disabilities, like autism. We want to highlight our call for an
autism-trained advocate to be offered to every adult with autism at
their first point of contact with the Department of Work and Pensions:
When the changeover from DLA to PIP is rolled out in April adults
with autism are looking at the prospect of having two face to face
assessments. People with autism and Asperger's syndrome have
difficulties with social communication and flexibility of thought. This
includes how to understand and work out what another person is thinking
or feeling by reading and interpreting body language, gesture and facial
expression.
People with autism who are non-verbal and have a learning disability
will have great difficulties in making their needs and wants understood
but tend to be accepted as needing advocacy which is often automatically
available to them through statutory support.
It is often assumed that as people with Asperger’s and High
Functioning Autism (HFA), who have average intellect and the ability to
talk, are therefore able to fully and comprehensively communicate and
state their view due to their verbal ability. It is this area in which
people with Asperger's/HFA are in great need of advocacy because
although they can physically talk they are not always able to explain
and express what they actually think or thought, intend or intended to
do or emotionally feel or felt using the medium of speech.
Autism is a complex disability and anyone who acts as an advocate
requires a good overall understanding of autism. There are very few
advocacy services that are freely available to adults with
Asperger's/HFA and even fewer advocacy services that have specifically
trained advocates to support people with autism.
Most adults with Asperger’s/HFA are not eligible for statutory
services and cannot access advocacy groups for a range of different
reasons. An advocate with a background in autism can explain the
condition of Asperger’s/HFA when attending a benefit assessment with the
individual. They can also write reports and support letters as even if
the person has intellectual capacity s/he may lack the insight into
her/his condition that the advocate can provide.
We are extremely concerned by comments being made by Esther McVay
that most adults transitioning from DLA to PIP will have historical
evidence which can be used to decide if they would require a face to
face assessment. There are thousands of adults with autism who have seen
no one about their condition since being signed off from Children’s
Services. This is because autism is not deemed to be a medical condition
and these adults have never been eligible for services despite their
lifelong need. Many adults with autism will simply have no evidence to
provide, historical or otherwise. This means that once again adults with
autism will be placed at a substantial disadvantage because their
disability does not fit neatly into a box.
PIP will require an adult to complete a questionnaire similar in
style to the ESA 50 Questionnaire which is long and difficult for
someone with autism to both interpret and answer. Autistic adults do not
always fully understand their own condition and this can mean that they
are not accurately answering some of the questions in the ESA 50 about
their functionality correctly or appropriately.
Functionality is what matters, not what the specific condition the person has.
Case study:
Client B was found “fit for work” at an Employment and Support
Allowance Work Capability Assessment; her benefits were stopped; amongst
other statements she told the health care professional that she did
“all her own cooking and meals”, so was assumed to be independent and
work ready. B suffered needless anxiety and stress while waiting 6
months for the appeal and self-isolated during this period; she appealed
the decision at tribunal with the help of an advocate’s report and
presence where it was explained that her “independent cooking” was
purely making toast and marmite for breakfast and microchips for her
tea, as she ate little else. Due to her phobias no one else could touch
her food. The advocate was essential for client B. ATOS Healthcare, DWP
decision makers and the tribunal time and costs could have been saved
plus the anxiety and stress endured by Client B if an advocate had been
available at her Work Capability Assessment.
Many people with autism cannot work and most (over 85%) of those even
with Asperger’s/HFA have never been successful in obtaining or
remaining in employment; their benefits have therefore been a source of
stability and a replacement for the lack of statutory support or autism
specific intervention that they should have been able to receive.
People with Asperger’s/HFA are now having their ESA re-assessed on a
regular basis and it can be removed, without much notice, by
professionals with little experience of Asperger’s /HFA. People with
Asperger’s/HFA look normal as it is a hidden disability, and their
intelligence and ability to speak can often be considered to be “fitness
to work”. The fitness for employment of a person with Asperger’s
syndrome is assessed by first answering questions on the ESA50 form
which expect some insight into their condition, which they many often
lack due and secondly measured in the WCA by questions about “a typical
day”. Their capacity to live independently and use a washing machine are
scored rather than the challenges they face due to their inability to
understand and process instructions, cope with colleagues, deal with
change and inconsistency in a work environment, and manage their anxiety
and stress levels.
We believe and are campaigning for advocacy to be offered to every
autistic adult at the first point of contact by the DWP, regardless of
their perceived work capability. 95% of adults with autism we asked said
they would prefer to be supported through the benefit process by an
autism-trained advocate.
Adults with Asperger’s syndrome/ HFA are now in constant state of
crisis and alarm, they are desperate and anxious as even if they succeed
in gaining ESA, they will soon be asked to complete the ESA50 again and
then attend another assessment to see if their autism and fitness to
work has improved. They also fear that, if the health professional or
decision maker does not understand their disability, their benefits will
be taken from them if the assessment is not successful.
It seems there is no end to this increasing cycle of assessments and
reassessments in their current format for people with Asperger’s/HFA and
the implementation of PIP will put ever more stress and pressure upon
autistic adults and their parents and/or carers.
It is essential to put in place robust advocacy services so some of
the most vulnerable in society, can continue to rely on the benefits to
which they should be entitled. Adults with Asperger’s/HFA need as much
and the same sort of advocacy as those who have autism and a learning
disability, and this service is cost effective and essential for their
mental and physical health and wellbeing. Advocacy is low level
preventative support at its best and would save money by reducing
appeals and tribunal costs.
Act Now For Autism
www.actnowforautism.co.uk
Written by Carole Rutherford (Act Now For Autism and AIM) and Sara Heath (Shropshire Autonomy)
CALL FOR ACTION
We are asking all supporters to email their MP's ahead of the
Atos Debate in the Main Chamber at Parliament this Thursday. We have written a sample
letter below, which you can copy and paste into an email and then personalise
with your own story if you have an Atos experience.
You can contact your
MP via the WriteToThem website: http://www.writetothem.com/
" Dear <insert MP name>
MPs are being given the opportunity to debate the Atos Work Capability
Assessment in the Main Chamber on Thursday 17th January. I support the
Act Now for Autism Campaign (www.actnowforautism.co.uk) and along with them I ask you to attend this
debate. Please add your voice to the growing concerns of the autism
community about the WCA.
Main Concerns:
The Work Capability Assessment is not ‘fit for purpose’ as a method
of assessing whether autistic adults are fit for work. Neither does it
identify those who may be able to work but would need a lot of support
to do so.
It would seem Clauses 3, 4 and 5 of section 20 of the Equality Act are being contravened. Reasonable adjustments are not being made and adults with
autism are being placed at a significant disadvantage to other people,
even compared to other disabilities and at present no steps are being taken
to avoid the disadvantage.
Despite autism being a communication disability, autistic adults are not being offered an
advocate to act as an auxiliary aid.
Part B10 of the Equalities Act is also being ignored
and is being breached during the assessment process, as the effects
of the environment in which the assessment is being carried out is not
being taken into consideration. Adults are becoming so
anxious by the process that it is seriously impacting on their ability
to function effectively on a daily basis.
Volunteer advocates within the autism community, who are living with
autism themselves, are having to guide adults with autism through
every step of the process, and have found that they cannot keep up with
the demand for their support. They often report they are then not
allowed to speak during the assessment by Atos heathcare professionals. Therefore, autistic adults are not being given the (equal) opportunity
to communicate effectively and neither are they then assessed fairly.
Act Now For Autism is campaigning for advocates to be offered to
every adult with autism at the first point of contact by the DWP, and for
separate autism-specific descriptors. Please see their Harrington WCA
3rd Year Review evidence for more information: http://autismcampaigners.blogspot.co.uk/2012/09/wca-year-3-call-for-evidence-our.html
I really hope you do speak up for the autistic adults in your
constituency, who are so often failed by
statutory services from the time they leave children's services and now also feel they are being classed as
'scroungers'. Please attend and speak up for them.
Yours faithfully
<insert your name> "