Showing posts with label #DWP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label #DWP. Show all posts

Friday, 10 January 2014

Sanctions





Today went sent our response to the independent review of Jobseeker's Allowance sanctions chaired by Matthew Oakley. (
https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/256044/jsa-sanctions-independent-review.pdf)

• To what extent do JSA claimants understand that when they are referred to a 'back-to-work' scheme (such as the Work Programme) their benefit may be sanctioned if they don't take part? 

Autism is a vast spectrum which is underpinned by communication and socialisation impairments. No matter where an adult with autism lies on the autistic spectrum they will have impaired communication and socialisation skills. Some adults with autism will struggle more than other to communicate effectively. One size simply does not fit all autistic adults.

While some adults with autism will understand that being sent on a ‘back to work’ scheme means, there will be many who do not fully understand what it means. 

One of the biggest issues for anyone who has autism is the ability to communicate effectively. Autism impacts on both expressive and receptive language. Unless the person who is communicating has been specifically trained to communicate effectively with someone who has autism we can never be sure that the person has fully understood what we are trying to convey. 

Stress and anxiety can and does impact on the functionality of someone with autism. When someone with autism is feeling extremely anxious and stressed they will try to extricate themselves from the situation that is creating their anxiety and stress as quickly as possible. That means that even if they do not understand what is being communicated to them, they will state that they do to enable them to remove themselves for that situation. 

• To what extent does a claimant’s failure to meet their conditions arise from them not having a sufficient understanding of what is expected? Are there ways in which this could be made clearer to them? 

Even if an adult with autism has fully understood that if they fail to comply with the ‘back to work’ scheme some adults will be totally overwhelmed by the actions that they need to carry out to stop them from being sanctioned. The fear of being sanctioned, will be for some adults, be the very reason why they fail to function effectively which will then result in them being sanctioned. Anxiety is an integral part of autism and increased levels of anxiety impacts on the functionality of the person with autism. 

It is not just about making it clear to someone with autism, although that is of course important, it is about having people who understand autism assigned to that person to support them through the ‘back to work’ scheme. 

Parents are telling us that they themselves are acting as the adults support structure and to ensure that they comply with the scheme, so that they are not at risk of being sanctioned. This is placing a huge amount of pressure on parents and carers who have told us that they feel that it is they who are being sanctioned because they have adult’s children with autism.

Adults with autism who do not have a parent or carer to support them are finding themselves under increasing pressure to comply with the scheme and we are being told by some adults that their mental and emotional wellbeing then suffers, with some having to seek expert help.

• Do sanctioned claimants understand why they have been sanctioned, and if not are there ways in which this could be made clearer to them? 

Again it is not just to do with understanding and it is not just about making it clear to people with autism. It is about having someone who understands the condition helping and supporting them through the sequence or process to ensure that they do comply with the scheme, and do not become so anxious about not fulfilling what they have to that they then fail. 

• Do sanctioned claimants feel informed throughout the sanctions process, and if not how could their awareness be improved? 

The issues that adults with autism face while they are on this scheme have to be addressed before they reach a point whereby they are sanctioned. At the moment we are setting adults with autism up to fail because their condition, and how it impacts, is not being fully understood by the Department of Work and Pension. This is something that Act Now for Autism believes needs to be urgently addressed. 

The whole process could be improved for adults with autism if an advocate was made available to them. That person would be able to get to know the individual communication preferences of autistic claimants, thereby perhaps reducing sanctions.

• To what extent are sanctioned claimants aware of the help available to them from Jobcentre Plus? For instance are they aware of how to appeal a decision or how to seek help through hardship payments? Are there ways in which this could be made clearer to them? 

Some of the adults that we have spoken to are not even aware that the JobCentre Plus has a disability employment officer. Of those who do, some are telling us that the disability employment officer has very little knowledge or understanding of their condition. 

Act Now for Autism has been calling for advocates for adults with autism to enable them to access the benefits/benefit assessment system since July 2010. Without the offer of an advocate adults with autism are being put at a substantial disadvantage to adults with other disabilities because of their impaired communication and socialisation skills. 

Adults with autism have problems with all forms of communication and that includes filling in the necessary forms to appeal a decision. The way in which to make the whole process accessible and clear for adults with autism is to make sure that there are autism specific advocates available to them who can support and enable them.

Sincerely 
Act Now For Autism 

Friday, 1 November 2013

Another postcode lottery, like we needed any more.

Last Friday the Department of Work and Pensions made an eleventh hour announcement that they are amending the timetable for inviting current Disability Living Allowance (DLA) claimants due to turn 16 to apply for Personal Independence Payments (PIP).
 
Given the concerns that Act Now for Autism has continually raised regarding the PIP assessment, and in particular the impact of a face to face assessment for anyone who has as autistic spectrum condition, the announcement should have been good news.

However, the whole process has not been paused. We are now facing a postcode lottery roll-out of PIP, which means that some children who are now approaching their 16th birthday will still likely have to endure a face to face assessment in the coming months. Any child who is living in Wales, the West Midlands, East Midlands, or East Anglia will still be invited to claim for PIP as their 16th Birthday approaches.

Some parents who had already received an invitation for their child to claim PIP have told us this week that following the announcement from the DWP they have received a letter from informing them that their child's DLA award will now continue for another 12 months before they can apply for PIP.

It is well documented and accepted by leading professionals that emotional age of a child with autism is often significantly different to their chronological age. We have already raised concerns about the morality of expecting a 16 year old with autism to endure a face to face assessment and we will continue to do so.

The prospect of their children being subjected to a face to face PIP assessment is creating an enormous amount of stress and anxiety for parent carers. Parents are telling us that their children simply will not be able to cope and account for themselves accurately such an assessment.

We are also hearing from parents who are extremely concerned that their children will not have the historical or medical evidence that we are constantly hearing will be required, before ensuring that a face to face assessment will not be necessary.

Autism is not considered to be a medical condition and there are now many areas across the UK where children are no longer seen on a regular basis by a paediatrician or a health professional who could supply up to date and in depth medical evidence about them. We know that some GP's are now delegating the job of filling in medical questionnaires on to their practice managers who do not even know the patients. Some GP's practices have even stopped filling in the questionnaire altogether as they simply do not have the time to do it and others charge a fee.

Once again we fear that anyone who has a diagnosis of autism is going to be placed at a significant disadvantage to someone who has a medical condition and are seen regularly by a health professional.


Monday, 26 August 2013

Finally, a reply...

We would like to thank the Minister Esther McVey for responding to our letter dated 11th April via one of our founders Anna Kennedy. We are pleased to hear that she "greatly admires and appreciates the valuable work" that we do, however we are very disappointed that she is unable to meet with us to discuss the concerns we raised again with her about the PIP assessment process (and the WCA) for adults with autism.

We feel the response from the Minister has somewhat missed the point(s) we raised. While we are fully aware that adults with autism are allowed an appointee and encouraged to take a companion with them, during face to face assessments, this does not always happen. Also the very nature of the condition means that some adults with autism will simply not have anyone whom they can ask to accompany them to an assessment.

Here is her reply, apologies for the poor (and squint) quality! 


The point that we were hoping to convey is autism impacts on all forms of communication, including written communication. That is why it is essential that an autism specific advocate is offered at the first point of contact by the DWP, ATOS or JobcentrePlus.
 
We know it is the adults who have not had the support of an advocate, while they are completing their ESA 50 questionnaire, who are most likely to find themselves having a face to face assessment and then being placed wrongly in a Work Related Activity Group whilst facing the trauma of having to launch an appeal. 

The point we were hoping to make to the Minister is that the whole assessment process discriminates against autistic adults because they have a communication and socialisation impairment.

Once again we reiterated there are a significant number of autistic adults who do not have the historical or medical data they require for decision makers to make a decision as to whether or not they might have to have a face to face assessment. There are many adults who have been without services and provision after being signed off by Children’s Services. 


No services and no provision does not equal someone who is not in need support!

We know that autistic adults are at a distinct disadvantage to other people with disabilities in the current system simply because they have either been unable to access services and provision, or the services and provision did not exist for them to access in the first place. 

 
We are extremely frustrated that no one within the Coalition Government and DWP appears to be able to understand that adults with autism are going to find themselves discriminated against and disadvantaged throughout the whole PIP process, as they are throughout the whole WCA process.

 
We will write again to the Minister and continue to reiterate these points! 



Monday, 4 February 2013

Call For Trained Advocates

Act Now For Autism supports the call for a Cumulative Impact Assessment of the Welfare Reform Act. The changes to benefits are falling disproportionately upon disabled communities across the UK and our particular concern is for those with hidden disabilities, like autism. We want to highlight our call for an autism-trained advocate to be offered to every adult with autism at their first point of contact with the Department of Work and Pensions:

When the changeover from DLA to PIP is rolled out in April adults with autism are looking at the prospect of having two face to face assessments. People with autism and Asperger's syndrome have difficulties with social communication and flexibility of thought. This includes how to understand and work out what another person is thinking or feeling by reading and interpreting body language, gesture and facial expression.

People with autism who are non-verbal and have a learning disability will have great difficulties in making their needs and wants understood but tend to be accepted as needing advocacy which is often automatically available to them through statutory support.

It is often assumed that as people with Asperger’s and High Functioning Autism (HFA), who have average intellect and the ability to talk, are therefore able to fully and comprehensively communicate and state their view due to their verbal ability. It is this area in which people with Asperger's/HFA are in great need of advocacy because although they can physically talk they are not always able to explain and express what they actually think or thought, intend or intended to do or emotionally feel or felt using the medium of speech.

Autism is a complex disability and anyone who acts as an advocate requires a good overall understanding of autism. There are very few advocacy services that are freely available to adults with Asperger's/HFA and even fewer advocacy services that have specifically trained advocates to support people with autism.
 Most adults with Asperger’s/HFA are not eligible for statutory services and cannot access advocacy groups for a range of different reasons. An advocate with a background in autism can explain the condition of Asperger’s/HFA when attending a benefit assessment with the individual. They can also write reports and support letters as even if the person has intellectual capacity s/he may lack the insight into her/his condition that the advocate can provide.

We are extremely concerned by comments being made by Esther McVay that most adults transitioning from DLA to PIP will have historical evidence which can be used to decide if they would require a face to face assessment. There are thousands of adults with autism who have seen no one about their condition since being signed off from Children’s Services. This is because autism is not deemed to be a medical condition and these adults have never been eligible for services despite their lifelong need. Many adults with autism will simply have no evidence to provide, historical or otherwise. This means that once again adults with autism will be placed at a substantial disadvantage because their disability does not fit neatly into a box.

PIP will require an adult to complete a questionnaire similar in style to the ESA 50 Questionnaire which is long and difficult for someone with autism to both interpret and answer. Autistic adults do not always fully understand their own condition and this can mean that they are not accurately answering some of the questions in the ESA 50 about their functionality correctly or appropriately.
Functionality is what matters, not what the specific condition the person has.

Case study:
Client B was found “fit for work” at an Employment and Support Allowance Work Capability Assessment; her benefits were stopped; amongst other statements she told the health care professional that she did “all her own cooking and meals”, so was assumed to be independent and work ready. B suffered needless anxiety and stress while waiting 6 months for the appeal and self-isolated during this period; she appealed the decision at tribunal with the help of an advocate’s report and presence where it was explained that her “independent cooking” was purely making toast and marmite for breakfast and microchips for her tea, as she ate little else. Due to her phobias no one else could touch her food. The advocate was essential for client B. ATOS Healthcare, DWP decision makers and the tribunal time and costs could have been saved plus the anxiety and stress endured by Client B if an advocate had been available at her Work Capability Assessment.

Many people with autism cannot work and most (over 85%) of those even with Asperger’s/HFA have never been successful in obtaining or remaining in employment; their benefits have therefore been a source of stability and a replacement for the lack of statutory support or autism specific intervention that they should have been able to receive.

People with Asperger’s/HFA are now having their ESA re-assessed on a regular basis and it can be removed, without much notice, by professionals with little experience of Asperger’s /HFA. People with Asperger’s/HFA look normal as it is a hidden disability, and their intelligence and ability to speak can often be considered to be “fitness to work”. The fitness for employment of a person with Asperger’s syndrome is assessed by first answering questions on the ESA50 form which expect some insight into their condition, which they many often lack due and secondly measured in the WCA by questions about “a typical day”. Their capacity to live independently and use a washing machine are scored rather than the challenges they face due to their inability to understand and process instructions, cope with colleagues, deal with change and inconsistency in a work environment, and manage their anxiety and stress levels.

We believe and are campaigning for advocacy to be offered to every autistic adult at the first point of contact by the DWP, regardless of their perceived work capability. 95% of adults with autism we asked said they would prefer to be supported through the benefit process by an autism-trained advocate.

Adults with Asperger’s syndrome/ HFA are now in constant state of crisis and alarm, they are desperate and anxious as even if they succeed in gaining ESA, they will soon be asked to complete the ESA50 again and then attend another assessment to see if their autism and fitness to work has improved. They also fear that, if the health professional or decision maker does not understand their disability, their benefits will be taken from them if the assessment is not successful.

It seems there is no end to this increasing cycle of assessments and reassessments in their current format for people with Asperger’s/HFA and the implementation of PIP will put ever more stress and pressure upon autistic adults and their parents and/or carers.

It is essential to put in place robust advocacy services so some of the most vulnerable in society, can continue to rely on the benefits to which they should be entitled. Adults with Asperger’s/HFA need as much and the same sort of advocacy as those who have autism and a learning disability, and this service is cost effective and essential for their mental and physical health and wellbeing. Advocacy is low level preventative support at its best and would save money by reducing appeals and tribunal costs.

Act Now For Autism
www.actnowforautism.co.uk

Written by Carole Rutherford (Act Now For Autism and AIM) and Sara Heath (Shropshire Autonomy) 

Sunday, 13 January 2013

Please Act NOW For Autism And Email Your MP!

CALL FOR ACTION

We are asking all supporters to email their MP's ahead of the Atos Debate in the Main Chamber at Parliament this Thursday. We have written a sample letter below, which you can copy and paste into an email and then personalise with your own story if you have an Atos experience. 

You can contact your MP via the WriteToThem website: http://www.writetothem.com/

" Dear <insert MP name>

MPs are being given the opportunity to debate the Atos Work Capability Assessment in the Main Chamber on Thursday 17th January. I support the Act Now for Autism Campaign (www.actnowforautism.co.uk) and along with them I ask you to attend this debate. Please add your voice to the growing concerns of the autism community about the WCA.

Main Concerns: 

The Work Capability Assessment is not ‘fit for purpose’ as a method of assessing whether autistic adults are fit for work. Neither does it identify those who may be able to work but would need a lot of support to do so.

It would seem Clauses 3, 4 and 5 of section 20 of the Equality Act are being contravened. Reasonable adjustments are not being made and adults with autism are being placed at a significant disadvantage to other people, even compared to other disabilities and at present no steps are being taken to avoid the disadvantage. 

Despite autism being a communication disability, autistic adults are not being offered an advocate to act as an auxiliary aid. 

Part B10 of the Equalities Act is also being ignored and is being breached during the assessment process, as the effects of the environment in which the assessment is being carried out is not being taken into consideration. Adults are becoming so anxious by the process that it is seriously impacting on their ability to function effectively on a daily basis. 

Volunteer advocates within the autism community, who are living with autism themselves, are having to guide adults with autism through every step of the process, and have found that they cannot keep up with the demand for their support. They often report they are then not allowed to speak during the assessment by Atos heathcare professionals. Therefore, autistic adults are not being given the (equal) opportunity to communicate effectively and neither are they then assessed fairly.

Act Now For Autism is campaigning for advocates to be offered to every adult with autism at the first point of contact by the DWP, and for separate autism-specific descriptors. Please see their Harrington WCA 3rd Year Review evidence for more information: http://autismcampaigners.blogspot.co.uk/2012/09/wca-year-3-call-for-evidence-our.html

I really hope you do speak up for the autistic adults in your constituency, who are so often failed by statutory services from the time they leave children's services and now also feel they are being classed as 'scroungers'. Please attend and speak up for them.

Yours faithfully

<insert your name> "